Reader Ad Slot
Reader Ad Slot placeholder
If you would like to support SpookStack without paying out of pocket, please consider allowing advertising cookies. It helps cover hosting costs and keeps the archive free to browse. You can change this choice at any time.
fbi-use-of-global-postioning-system-gps-tracking — Part 01
Page 12
12 / 32
asked him whether he was carrying any contraband or large sums of money, which
Maynard offers as further evidence he was "under duress," is irrelevant for the same
reason.
We agree with the district court that, considering all the circumstances surrounding the
stop, a reasonable person in Maynard's position would have felt free to decline
Whitehead's request that he answer "a few additional questions." See United States v.
Wylie, 569 F.2d 62, 67 (D.C.Cir.1977) ("police-citizen communications which take place
under circumstances in which the citizen's freedom to walk away' is not limited by
anything other than his desire to cooperate do not amount to 'seizures' of the person').
Whitehead had already returned Maynard's license and registration and told him he was
free to go. Although there were by that time three police cars (two of which were
unmarked) on the scene, Whitehead's words and actions unambiguously conveyed to
Maynard his detention was at an end. After that, Maynard returned to the front of the van.
a clear sign he thought he was free to go. By remaining behind the vehicle as Maynard
left, Whitehead further assured Maynard he would not impede his leaving. Finally,
Maynard turned around and came back only when Whitehead re-initiated the stop by
asking him if he would answer a few more questions. That Whitehead shouted the
question might in some circumstances turn it into a show of authority, but not here; the
two were standing some distance apart on the side of a noisy interstate highway. In sum.
the police did not seize Maynard by asking him whether he would answer a few more
questions.
The appellants' brief might be read to argue the extension of the stop, from the time
Whitehead frisked Maynard until the dog alerted, was a separate seizure. See United
States v. Alexander, 448 F.3d 1014, 1016 (8th Cir.2006) (dog sniff "may be the.product
of an unconstitutional seizure [ ] if the traffic stop is unreasonably prolonged before the
dog is employed"). If Maynard's and Gordon's inconsistent statements, Maynard's
claimed lack of knowledge about Gordon, and Gordon's nervousness had not already
created "reasonable suspicion to believe that criminal activity [was] afoot," United States
v. Arvizu, 534 U.S. 266, 273 (2002) (internal quotation marks deleted), however, then
surely the addition of Maynard's agitated reaction to Whitehead's renewed questioning
did, see Illinois v. Wardlow, 528 U.S. 119, 123 (2000) ( "nervous, evasive behavior is a
pertinent factor in determining reasonable suspicion').
*6 The parties also dispute whether Maynard's consent to the search of the van was
voluntary and whether Jones has standing to challenge that search. Those issues are
mooted by our holding the extension of the stop to ask Maynard a few additional
questions was not a seizure and any subsequent extension of the stop leading up to the
canine sniff was supported by reasonable suspicion. The appellants do not dispute the
district court's determination that the police had probable cause to search the van once the
dog alerted. Accordingly, we hold the district court properly admitted evidence the police
discovered by searching the van.
C. Superseding Indictment
7TTUOTD
COTCES
Community corrections
No user corrections yet.
Comments
No comments on this document yet.
Bottom Reader Ad Slot
Bottom Reader Ad Slot placeholder
If you would like to support SpookStack without paying out of pocket, please consider allowing advertising cookies. It helps cover hosting costs and keeps the archive free to browse. You can change this choice at any time.
Continue Exploring
Agency Collection
Explore This Archive Cluster
Broad Topic Hub
letter
bureau
Related subtopics
Subtopic
Subtopic
Subtopic
Subtopic
Subtopic
Subtopic