◆ SpookStack

Tatm GIavin Ir. Ladd Niebo Ur. Rosen Traey Supreme Court Mr. Acers Mr. Carton Controversy Mr. Harbo Mr. Hendon lares Again Mr. Mumlord Mr. Starke Eo ge Asrociate Press Justice Felix Franfurter added Mr. Quinn Tamm Jaa JueI ye terd y to the, coniro- Mr. Neas. Hry gmong Supreme Court Jur. Won over. ho' Int rpret tlon. o! Miss Gaady t hccoljearues.wre resorting Spotrine of con titutional lax? Takes Szoeytiom The. wern yirtually tho sam. I Whare tha reorganization sujer- Forda Justtces Black and Murphy se ... prlor ptoceeding in eitper th Fedarel or Btats court, the Hanknurtar's ylews on ytllty rato baruptcy court li the one wlich makdins. is sthorlzd to allow the reason. latast tff developed over abl posts and expeates' incurred th E court's dacislon that Fedtral intheprior proceeding," the bapkruptcy. Iatherthan op ten satd. St3te courts. has, exclusive power Lut Franxfurter asserted that tx foes.for.attorneyn.who_rep frr. 'the beginning Congress had J05 nnos og oqt af pa aHowed Federally created rights to ptation undergoing reorganization bo onforced in State courts "not only by the general implicatlons. ranturter agreed with ti the Of our legal system but also by ex-. Ofar justlees that in this paftleu- pllcit authorization." oass ine bankruptcy pourt Ho deciared that the Constitu- Shzuld detarmine the fees bet ve: ton does not give the Bankruptcy hg nently expressed oppositlon, In Act supremacy.over the right of concurring opinion. to the States to determine wh:t shall be Bhunds which tho Supreme Oourt litigated in theircourts, and Chad ier its dnding. under what conditions. TThe case Invoived the reorgani- "And certainly." be added, "such zstJon the Reynolds Investing a wholly novel doctrine of constitu- Inc, in the Yederal Dlstrict tional Iaw should not be resorted JIt of New Jergey. Thre. attor. togratultously when.the case le- S acting tor the debtor,-and later foje us can be dispcsed of on the foy.trustees for the company. nled cdhclusive ground that the litita- st in ths New York courts to col- tjn conducted in the New Ydrk le certaln elaims. Before judg- courts was conducted under an ar- hts wers'returned, the attorneys' rangement consonant with New Zices were discontinued. There. York law.. Un, upder New York State judi- Ty law and In conformity with ar arrangemeut in the reorganiea- proqeodlng, the thres sued in State courts to obtaln fees for thi I inrvices, and were swarded .000: /2-2J5A astise Dougdas' opinion decli red S undar thapter io of the Bynk. ITCOrDED W Aot, Con re had oonfetted Famount and pxciudre" juhis. GT FEB 12 1944 on.oa the bankruptcy court. FE38 WASHINGTON POST Page.