◆ SpookStack

Declassified Document Archive & Reader
Log In Register
Reader Ad Slot
Reader Ad Slot placeholder
If you would like to support SpookStack without paying out of pocket, please consider allowing advertising cookies. It helps cover hosting costs and keeps the archive free to browse. You can change this choice at any time.

Supreme Court — Part 27

83 pages · May 11, 2026 · Document date: Sep 2, 1958 · Broad topic: General · Topic: Supreme Court · 82 pages OCR'd
← Back to feed
*. > - 0-19 (Rev, 7-16-58) ‘ The Washington Mérry-Go-Roni ourage ia es Co ie rete OP pee eg In Vote 6. * ; UNFORGETTABLE ‘scenes : Were stamped on the minds} “of Senators as the last weary] ‘ days of the 85th Congress : dragged to a "close. Most . poignant of all , Was the 4140°'% , Vote to table ag _ the resolution & , curtailing the. oOwers of the: Supreme _Court. As the “vole was an- o nounced John .'y cClellan of earson .Atkansas trem- P : ‘bled. Perspiration stood out § on his forehead. He was white B with anger... Twenty years before, another Arkansas Sen-|B ator had stood on the Sengte'# ‘power of the Supreme Court aq leader, Joe Robinson of Ar- |i * Kansas was loyal to his chief _ in the White House, and when ‘ President Roosevelt . intro- duced his court-packing bill, . Robinson fought for it.. .His . heart, however, was never in < his argument. His heart. was ; with his southern friends, Sen- ; ator “Jimmy” Byrnes of South§ Carolina, Harry Byrd of Vir- ; ginia, Walter George and Dick ‘Russell of Georgia, .- - ; So Robinson, overworked _and heartsick, died during the ‘court battle. His heart failed ‘him . - Last week Joh: Me- ‘Clellan, "tired from the long Hoffa hearings, looked as if he might collapse as the one- vote margin to prapanuethe in dspenuerte of the court was Fas 5 'C SEP 9° 1958 e ‘on Court on _ By Drew Pore A 2he i “nullification” os “¢ ginia looked calm. Twenty| Mfcyears before he had battled r against Roosevelt to keep the floor also arguing that the ime ‘ must be curbed. As majority a , oa ak |Rrecping testy ‘Shown fncering eid. Oe ily they reused this a: iNorth-South Democratic bat, itle, oné which would play up _the split inside the Democratic ‘Party .. . Unkindest vote of all came from Sen. Kuchel of California, Republican. He threw’ in, his lot with thi enemies of Chief Justice War- ren, though it was Warren, ‘when Governor of California, lwho appointed Kuchel to the Senate . Margaret Chase Smith of Maine, the only lady, lined up against the court which had supported her in various, decisions on McCar.- thyism ; : . Gore of Tennessee]: took the easy course; his col- league. Kefauver the hard course. Kefauver’s vote for the court was one of only three from the South. Gore had just]: been assured of reelection.|. Kefauver comes up for reelec-|§ tion in 1960. His vote took real courage. So did the votes of Johnson and Yarborough, of]: Texas, — What ‘is courage? The word “courage” was, tossed’ arohnd the Senate floor like a basket- ball. Almost every Senator was complimenting almost every other Senator on his great courage. Most of them had shown no great courage. It_ takes no -courage for a No thern Senator representing egrd bloc of big city voters to Tine up for civil rights or for the Supreme Court. In con- > one announcd:,.. . Senator Strom Theenrond= of " SoutheCacolipa was not so emotional. But be- hind’ his flashing eyes and stern features you could s the same emotions that must have welled up in another fam-), ous South Carolinian, John C.& Calhoun, as he championed, . Byrd of Vir-| ‘Supreme Court independent. :Three years before he had joined with all of Virginia in payitig tribute te John Mar- shall, who as Chief Justice had established, in his fight with Jefferson, the independence of the Supreme Court. . . Grandson of a slave holder, ‘Sen. Tom Hennings of Mls- -souri, whose great grandfather “held more slaves than any other plantation owner in Georgia and whose grand- father was an officer in the Confederate Army, led - the Senate argument for the court. “In. these late anys of the session,” he said, “the Senate}, may be doing something which| |trast, Kefauver - Yarborough- will plague not only the Sen-). |Johnson votes did take cou: ate, but the people of the coun.| | ,7#8e- Johnsen even persuaded try, other Senates and other ‘George Smathers of Florida, Cohgresses for years to come,”|.| Who was against the court, to . Sen. John Carroll of Colo-| | pair with Mike Monroney_ of irado supported Hennings. . Oklahoma who, though for , Silent Rep 4 court, was absent. This gave bat, iefly between Dem. ‘| the one-vote margin needed | ose fepublicans voted) for the court... Furthermore, Johnsqn had persuaded Sens. Bob Kerr of Oklahoma and ‘Allen Frear pf Delaware, both Democrats who would have| vated against the court, to re-F main.in the cloakroom and not vote. As the vote was taken, ‘Democratic Whip Mansfield of |! x ontan ; announced: enator from L 2. 228 WS Fs: 5 - It '(Frear), the Senator from Flor-|' da (Holland), and the Sena- — an DED ors from Oklahoma*(Kert and NOT 8 1958 Mora from ( are ‘absent on offi- 184 SEP ial business.” This was not exactly true.. Holland was yorida campaigning frantica for his renomination, whit ery and Frear were in’ ele..Room __ Holloman Gandy —__.__ Wash. Post and LA Times Herald Wash, News Wash. Star N. Y. Herald —___ Tribune N.Y. Journal-___ American N.Y. N, Y, N.Y. Mirror Daily News ___ Times Daily Worker The Worker New Leader Date AUG 27 1958
OCR quality for this page
Community corrections
First editor: none yet Last editor: none yet
No user corrections yet.
Comments
Document-wide discussion. Follow the Community Standards.
No comments on this document yet.
Bottom Reader Ad Slot
Bottom Reader Ad Slot placeholder
If you would like to support SpookStack without paying out of pocket, please consider allowing advertising cookies. It helps cover hosting costs and keeps the archive free to browse. You can change this choice at any time.

Continue Exploring

Use the strongest next step for this document: continue reading, jump to the topic hub, or move into the matching agency collection.
Continue Reading at Page 15
Jump straight to page 15 of 83.
Reader
Supreme Court — Part 20
Stay inside Supreme Court with another closely related document.
Topic
FBI Documents & FOIA Archive
Open the FBI agency landing page for stronger archive context.
FBI
Supreme Court Topic Hub
See the topic overview, related documents, and linked subtopics.
Hub

Agency Collection

This document also belongs in the FBI Documents & FOIA Archive landing page, which is the stronger starting point for agency-level browsing and for searches focused on FBI records.
FBI Documents & FOIA Archive
Open the agency landing page for introduction text, topic links, and more FBI documents.
FBI

Explore This Archive Cluster

This document belongs to the General archive hub and the more specific Supreme Court topic page. Use these hub pages when you want the broader collection context, linked subtopics, and more documents around the same archive thread.
letter bureau
Related subtopics
John Murtha
57 documents · 1471 known pages
Subtopic
Sen Joseph Joe Mccarthy
42 documents · 2653 known pages
Subtopic
D B Cooper
41 documents · 13789 known pages
Subtopic
Kansas City Massacre
38 documents · 5300 known pages
Subtopic
Black Panther Party
36 documents · 3066 known pages
Subtopic
Malcolm X
36 documents · 3932 known pages
Subtopic