◆ SpookStack

"a Ca. eee | hers mete eine sen Ep % Re ep mee me ti - te ee SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES. ee a ee ae No, 25 —(pctones Temy, 1942. Henjemin McNabb, Freeman Me. Nabb, and Raymon? MeNabb, Petitioners, Oo Writ of Certerari te the Voted Staves ‘ireoit Court of Arpeas for the ws. : firth Cirenit. The United Mtates cf America } [March 1, 1949; Mr dusti-e Brow, dimenting I find myectf wnalle to agree with the epmim of th) Coart in thi: case An offer of the United States wae killed woo- om the perforbance of tus duties From the circumstance Jaded in the Court's opinien, there wae obvious peason te aamjewt that the petiteciens bere eere amy icated in dring tte fate) ehet fem the dark (The arrests Followed Ae the gudty partes wee known enis ts the McoNaths who took partin the assault at ©- turing greur 5 it wes natural and proper that the offeers wos 2 jcestion them an te their actions! The easen just cited abow that atetements mate we - under interrogation mas be wend at a trial fit tuay feisty te sand that ay the information we. given coluntarily, A frank art free con few: noof eritae by the cuiprat af-nde tewtimeny of + uoghest eredibility andaf a character etich gay be verified eae Ey oaty frark reaponecs to officers by mnnocent peuple artested . cer mis. apprebension give the bent basse for preempt diactarpe fh + enptonds . Tie realuation of the ropvineing quality ef a confess 2 tests efivia's to prem suspects nmdury fur anei statements ¢- ruard acum] pereie aganat the Wanger of brig fub-ed to. coe tbe aw admits confemions of guilt only when thes are co etarily male While the conuetatom of sulanlary ® iwieGrite © a% nls - an woderatandable label ctafer etueh can be reality claw “ed the | BEL MET ee aT FOES ee Tn TS _, warsys acts of terropumm, prune, trickery and thengte wo ch have . Jed this and ether sourts to refuse admieion as eviier vy to fon Th BBh; Mgr ad Manare + Maat Biota. (ates, $35. Wiles + United py he ee Pre ta 18.